What happens when the economy no longer needs as many people to work as it once did?

Germany is beginning to confront a question that governments around the world will increasingly have to address.

According to Andrea Nahles, head of Germany’s Federal Employment Agency, artificial intelligence could eliminate approximately 800,000 jobs over the next 15 years. A similar number of new jobs may emerge, but that does not mean the transition will be painless.

Some sectors, including business services, banking and insurance, are expected to experience significant disruption. Even where new jobs are created, workers may not have the skills, experience or opportunities needed to move into them.

Interestingly, Germany’s political conversation is also beginning to shift.

Chancellor Friedrich Merz, traditionally cautious about universal basic income, has acknowledged that AI could fundamentally change the world of work and that the question of basic income deserves serious consideration.

Digital Transformation Minister Karsten Wildberger has gone further, suggesting that unconditional basic income could help cushion the disruption.

These are significant developments. But I think there is a much bigger question we need to ask.

Is the purpose of basic income simply to compensate people when AI takes their jobs, or should it be about ensuring everyone benefits from the productivity and wealth that AI creates?

There is an important distinction here.

A narrow approach sees basic income as a safety net for a future in which fewer people have access to paid employment. It is essentially about managing the consequences of technological disruption.

A broader approach starts from a different premise: economic security should not depend entirely on someone’s ability to secure employment in an increasingly automated economy.

If AI allows businesses to produce more with fewer workers, the gains in productivity should not accrue exclusively to technology companies, investors and shareholders. Society must also have a way of sharing those gains.

This is where Universal Basic Income (UBI) becomes relevant.

A regular, unconditional income would give people a degree of economic security regardless of their employment status. It could provide breathing room during periods of transition, support unpaid care and community work, and give people greater freedom to decide how they participate in the economy.

Of course, basic income is not a substitute for quality public services, education, worker protections or meaningful employment. Nor does it remove the need to address how AI is owned, controlled and taxed.

But it offers an important foundation for a more inclusive economic model.

One observation from the DW article particularly stands out. Kirsten Herrmann of Mein Grundeinkommen argues that basic income should provide people with a secure economic foundation before a crisis in the labour market happens, rather than being introduced only when jobs disappear.

I agree.

We should not wait for mass unemployment to start discussing economic security.

The AI transition is not simply a technological challenge. It is a question of economic justice, ownership and how society distributes the benefits of human innovation.

The future of work should not be reduced to finding new jobs for people displaced by technology. It should also be about building an economy in which technological progress improves people’s lives, strengthens their freedom and gives everyone a fair share of the prosperity it creates.

Perhaps the most important question is not whether AI will take our jobs, but whether we are prepared to rethink the relationship between work, income and human wellbeing.

Read the full DW article: https://www.dw.com/en/how-ai-is-likely-to-change-germanys-job-market/a-79941597