Podcast on Basic Income #5 (13/11/11)

Respective Links:
0:33 The United Kingdom – David Jenkins
https://binews.org/2013/11/david-jenkins-%e2%80%9cwhy-reciprocity-might-be-bullshit%e2%80%9d/

1:02 Ireland – Basic Income Ireland Network
https://binews.org/2013/11/celbridge-ireland-public-event-about-basic-income-november-23rd-2013/

buy augmentin online augmentin online generic

1:33 Switzerland – Tom Boland
https://binews.org/2013/11/tom-boland-%e2%80%9ccolumn-should-every-citizen-receive-an-unconditional-basic-income%e2%80%9d/

2:00 Switzerland
https://binews.org/2013/11/segacious-news-network-%e2%80%9c2750-a-month-for-every-adult-guaranteed-switzerland%e2%80%99s-considering-it%e2%80%9d/

2:23 Switzerland – The citizen’s initiative has been formally accepted
https://binews.org/2013/11/switzerland-citizen%e2%80%99s-initiative-formally-accepted/

2:56 Germany – World Movement of Christian Workers
https://binews.org/2013/11/charo-castello-%e2%80%9cwmcw-international-plan-of-action-%e2%80%98for-a-universal-basic-income%e2%80%99%e2%80%9d/

4:02 Kenya – Cash to the poor: Pennies from heaven
https://binews.org/2013/11/the-economist-%e2%80%9ccash-to-the-poor-pennies-from-heaven-giving-money-directly-to-poor-people-works-surprisingly-well-but-it-cannot-deal-with-the-deeper-causes-of-poverty%e2%80%9d/

5:00 European Union – Croatia, Sweden and Portugal
https://binews.org/2013/11/the-european-initiative-for-basic-income-begins-crowd-sourcing-campaign/

5:57 Book Review – Karl Widerquist
https://binews.org/2013/11/karl-widerquist-independence-propertylessness-and-basic-income-a-theory-of-freedom-as-the-power-to-say-no/

7:18 Brazil – Opinion of Eduardo Suplicy
https://binews.org/2013/11/opinion-one-step-towards-dignity/

You can reach us via Twitter: https://twitter.com/BINews

OPINION: One step towards dignity

The 81 senators, representing the 27 units of the Federation, 16 political parties, including two former presidents of the Republic, one current and two former presidents of the Senate, two likely candidates for the Presidency, 20 ex-governors and 18 ex-mayors, have signed a letter to president Dilma Rousseff, handed in by me on October 25th, with a proposal: she should appoint a working group with the purpose of paving the way for the institution, step by step, starting with those most in need, of the Citizenship Basic Income (CBI), according to Law No. 10.835/2004, approved by all political parties in the Brazilian National Congress. It is the first country in the world where the parliament has approved a law to that effect.

On October 30th

online pharmacy purchase clonidine online generic

, in the Museum of the Republic, in Brasilia, there was a ceremony to commemorate the tenth anniversary of the Bolsa Família Program implementation, which has crucially contributed to the eradication of extreme poverty and to the reduction of inequality in Brazil. This program can be seen as a step towards the CBI.

Next January 8th, the law establishing the CBI will celebrate its tenth anniversary. It is important, therefore, that people who have contributed to the study of income transfer programs can collaborate for this purpose, such as Professor Paul Singer, Secretary of the Solidarity Economy of the Ministry of Labor and Employment since 2003.

Professor Singer will be able to work in close cooperation with ministers Tereza Campello (Social Development), Miriam Belchior (Planning) and Marcelo Neri (Strategic Affairs) and with Ana Maria Medeiros da Fonseca, first Executive Secretary of the Bolsa Família – people who have contributed to its creation and to the formulation of policies in the area.

International experts may also be invited. One of them could be Professor Philippe Van Parijs, who founded the “Basic Income Earth Network” and follows the development of international experiences of implementing the CBI in the European Union, India, Iran, Namibia, Alaska, Switzerland, and other countries. The pioneer 30-year experience in Alaska has made it the most equal of American States.

The proposal, enthusiastically signed by each and every senator, including the opposition leaders and presidential candidates, is consistent with what has been formulated by some 300 scholars from Brazil and from abroad, who have recently participated in the International Conference of the Center for Psychopathology and Public Policy, at the University of São Paulo, on Democratic Inventions: Constructions of Happiness, and who have also signed a letter to president Dilma with the same purpose. Professor Marilena Chaui was one of the most enthusiastic subscribers.

We have had great achievements in the Workers Party’s last ten years of government, featuring the improvement of the disadvantaged populations’ living conditions. The 81 senators’ voices will allow the president to take a leap and achieve her goal of eradicating extreme poverty, building a fair nation, strengthening women’s safety and providing dignity to all Brazilians.

Karl Widerquist, Independence, Propertylessness, and Basic Income: A theory of freedom as the power to say no

Karl Widerquist, Independence, Propertylessness, and Basic Income: A theory of freedom as the power to say no, Palgrave Macmillan, 2013, 1 137 27472 4, hbk, xiv + 241 pp, £62.50

online pharmacy buy rogaine online no prescription pharmacy
online pharmacy buy mobic without prescription with best prices today in the USA
online pharmacy purchase sildalis online with best prices today in the USA
online pharmacy buy clomid online no prescription pharmacy

The message of this book is simple: We are not free; we ought to be; and a Citizen’s Income (called here a ‘Basic Income Guarantee’) is an important means to that end.

The ‘propertylessness’ in the title represents the diagnosis: that is, that someone who is without sufficient property to meet his or her basic needs is reliant on property owners for the meeting of those needs (through an employment contract, state benefits, or some other mechanism) and is therefore not free. Starting from a definition of freedom as non-interference, Widerquist develops a theory of ‘status freedom’: ‘the effort to identify the difference between a free person and an unfree person’, and also a refined definition of freedom as ‘effective control self-ownership … freedom as the power to say no’ (p.15). Co-operation with others should always be voluntary, which means that it should be from a position of genuine independence: and it is this ‘independentarianism’ that requires an individuals’ right to property and therefore to a Citizen’s Income.

In this book Widerquist draws out the implications of freedom as effective control self-ownership, and particularly its relationship to the individual’s co-operation with other individuals, to the labour market, to our ability willingly to sign away our freedoms, and to such theoretical positions as Philippe Van Parijs’s ‘real freedom’ (a positive freedom to do as one wishes consistent with others’ freedoms) and Stuart White’s ‘justice as fair reciprocity’.

Alongside this somewhat abstract discussion of concepts, Widerquist studies today’s social and economic context, and concludes that

in a modern, industrial economy [effective control self-ownership] is best secured by an unconditional basic income guarantee large enough to secure housing, food, clothing, and basic transportation, plus enough more that individuals do not display signs of economic distress (p.70)

and also that a Citizen’s Income is compensation for our inability to provide everyone with sufficient status independence (p.71).

There is no attempt to escape the logic of capitalism. Trade is a perfectly just mechanism if undertaken by independent individuals and by mutual agreement; and Widerquist shows how a moral obligation to participate can be satisfied better by voluntary participation than by mandatory participation:

Even if people have an obligation to contribute to a just system of social cooperation, giving individuals the power to say no to working conditions they find unacceptable might be a better method to create a just system of social cooperation than giving a democratic majority the powers both to determine the conditions of fair cooperation and to enforce participation. (p.117)

For Widerquist, the individual’s freely-chosen consent to participate is paramount: a freely chosen consent that can only be guaranteed by the existence of an exit option: that is, by the ability not to participate.

This book is many things: an exercise in political economy; a textbook on philosophy and social ethics (particularly in chapter 9 on ‘duty’); and a sustained argument for a Citizen’s Income: and it is an excellent example of all of them.

However, there remains a problem with terminology. For a UK audience, the language of ‘guarantee’ is confusing. A ‘guarantee’ of an income is a promise that someone’s income will reach a particular level, and this can be achieved by a means-tested benefit as well as by a universal one. The previous Labour Government’s Minimum Income Guarantee was means-tested, and was as far from a universal benefit as it is possible to get. It is unconditionality, individuality and universality that matter, and Widerquist might have stressed these important characteristics of a Citizen’s Income more than he has.

But having said that, this is an important contribution to the literature on universal benefits, and therefore to the debate that might one day lead to their extension to working age adults.

Podcast on Basic Income #4 (13/11/04)

Respective Links:
0:33 United States – Dissident Voice
https://binews.org/2013/10/kevin-zeese-margaret-flowers-%e2%80%9ctime-for-an-economy-of-by-and-for-the-people%e2%80%9d/

1:03 United States – David Graeber
https://binews.org/2013/10/arthur-de-grave-benjamin-tincq-%e2%80%9ccan-debt-catalyse-the-next-global-rebellion-an-interview-with-david-graeber/

1:32 Switzerland – French-speaking Swiss radio network
https://binews.org/2013/10/audio-van-parijs-on-the-swiss-radio/

2:05 Switzerland – Enno Schmidt
https://binews.org/2013/10/video-the-swiss-activist-who-collected-100000-signatures-to-provide-every-adult-citizen-with-2800month/

2:27 European citizens’ initiative petition
https://binews.org/2013/10/european-union-citizens%e2%80%99-initiative-for-basic-income-can-be-signed-online/

3:00 Uganda – Christopher Blattman
https://binews.org/2013/11/georgette-jasen-research-finds-outright-grants-of-cash-are-surprisingly-effective-form-of-aid-to-the-poor/

online pharmacy order amitriptyline without prescription with best prices today in the USA

3:31 Croatia, European Union, Slovenia
https://binews.org/2013/11/eu-slovenia-has-become-the-second-country-to-reach-the-target/

4:00 United Kingdom – CIT
https://binews.org/2013/11/citizen%e2%80%99s-income-trust-citizen%e2%80%99s-income-news-letter/

4:18 Cyprus – Malcolm Torry
https://binews.org/2013/11/opinion-means-testing-in-cyprus/

You can reach us via Twitter: https://twitter.com/BINews

OPINION: Means-testing in Cyprus

The President of Cyprus has announced the establishment of a ‘Guaranteed Minimum Income’. ‘Beneficiaries will be all of our fellow citizens who have an income below that which can assure them a dignified living.’ 4 That is, it will be a means-tested benefit. It will also be work-tested, which of course it will have to be, because means-tested benefits are withdrawn as earned income rises and so fail to provide the employment and enterprise incentives that an economy and a labour market need if they are to recover.

The benefit will do what it says: it will guarantee to all citizens a minimum income; but because it will go to some and not to others, it will not provide the social cohesion that Cyprus needs, and it will come with a substantial administrative price tag attached.

The President says that ‘the troika had accepted the government’s proposal “for a modern conceptualization on the policy of social welfare and prosperity”’. 4 The troika (the European Commission, the European Central Bank, and the International Monetary Fund) will have accepted the scheme because it matches the means-tested systems that other countries involved operate, and particularly those operating in the USA and the UK.

There are two lessons to be drawn here. One is that means-testing is an intuitive default position even though it is inefficient, costly, socially divisive, and entirely unnecessary in the context of a progressive income tax system. This default position means that it will not be easy for a social security system based on universal benefits to rise to the top of governments’ policy agendas, even though universal benefits are efficient, are cheap to administer, incentivize employment, self-employment and enterprise generally, are financially feasible, and are conducive to social cohesion.

The second lesson is that the word ‘guarantee’ is so ambiguous that advocates of universal benefits should stop using it. ‘Basic Income Guarantee’ is generally intended to mean the guarantee of a universal benefit, a concept that is at the opposite end of the spectrum from the means-tested ‘guaranteed minimum income’ proposed in Cyprus. The former means a Citizen’s Income; the latter a minimum net income guaranteed to a household by a means-tested benefits system. The previous Labour Government’s ‘Minimum Income Guarantee’ for pensioners was of the latter variety, and so particularly in the UK context we should be especially careful to reserve ‘guarantee’ language for a minimum net income to be reached by means of means-tested benefits, and never to use the word in the context of a discussion of universal benefits.

We would be content to forgive the President of Cyprus his use of the word ‘guarantee’ if he had meant by it a Citizen’s Income. But he did not.

1 www.labour.org.uk/one-nation-social-security-reform-miliband-speech#
2 www.schoolfoodplan.com/plan/
3 Kate Bell, ‘Investing in childhood’, Fabian Review, vol. 125, no.2, Summer 2013, p.19.
4 https://cyprus-mail.com/2013/07/26/president-announces-guaranteed-minimum-income-for-all-citizens/

Podcast on Basic Income #3 (13/10/28)

Respective Links:
Links:
0:34 Stumbling and Mumbling “Why not a basic income?”
https://binews.org/2013/10/stumbling-and-mumbling-why-not-a-basic-income/

0:54 United Kingdom – Tom Streithorst
https://binews.org/2013/10/tom-streithorst-%e2%80%9cbasic-income-and-the-atavistic-appeal-of-austerity%e2%80%9d/

1:22 Denmark – Philippe Van Parijs
https://binews.org/2013/10/copenhagen-denmark-%e2%80%9clectures-with-philippe-van-parijs%e2%80%9d-nov-1-2-2013/

2:20 The United States – USA Today
https://binews.org/2013/10/duncan-black-minimum-income-proposal-worth-considering/

2:38 The United States – Matt Bruenig
https://binews.org/2013/10/matt-bruenig-how-a-universal-basic-income-would-affect-poverty/

3:12 Canada – BIEN congress
https://binews.org/2013/10/bien-congress-2014-now-available-on-facebook-and-twitter/

3:59 Belgium – De Morgen
https://binews.org/2013/10/basic-income-makes-the-headlines-in-belgium/

5:20 Europe – Guy Standing
https://binews.org/2013/10/guy-standing-to-give-several-presentations-on-basic-income-in-italy-norway-finland-and-the-united-kingdom-2-13-november-2013/

5:43 Switzerland – Daniel Haeni
https://binews.org/2013/10/interview-daniel-haeni-on-the-swizz-initiative/

You can reach us via Twitter: https://twitter.com/BINews