Bart de Baan, “Hoe bevrijdend is de ‘eis’ van een onvoorwaardelijk basisinkomen? [A Leftist critique on Basic Income]”

This essay praises some aspects of basic income, but argues that the proposal has disadvantages from the leftist point of view, including that it doesn’t move toward a leftist vision and that it is “nationalism in disguise.”

Language: Original in Dutch. Translated into English.

Dutch version: Bart de Baan, “Hoe bevrijdend is de ‘eis’ van een onvoorwaardelijk basisinkomen? [A Leftist critique on Basic Income].” Doorbraak.eu, 24, January 2014.

Translated into English as “A Leftist critique on Basic Income,” by Revolution News, February 1, 2014.

-Revolution News

-Revolution News

Shamus Khan, “The marriage of poverty and inequality.”

SUMMARY: This article focuses on poverty and inequality, discussing how poverty puts people in a condition in which they cannot make meaningful choices. “Instead, we might look to policies like a guaranteed basic income or a negative income tax, in which we give people money and treat them with the dignity their humanity entitles them to. … Not only would it help those who are suffering get by, but rather than treating them like social degenerates, it would trust and empower them to make their own financial decisions. Given how much responsibility the more fortunate among us have for the problems plaguing the poor, it is the least our society can do.” The author, Shamus Khan is an associate professor of sociology at Columbia University. He is the author of Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Paul’s School.

Shamus Khan, “The marriage of poverty and inequality: Who is responsible when people don’t have enough?Al Jazeera America. February 20, 2014.

Shaun Loney, "Minimum income can end poverty"

Image: Bank of Montreal (bmo.com)

[Craig Axford]

A guaranteed annual income targeting the 100,000 citizens of Manitoba that are currently living below the after tax low-income cutoff would cost about $1.2 billion.  According to this article, with a willing federal partner the province that was home to the 1970s Minicome experiment could make it happen.

Shaun Loney, “Minimum income can end poverty”, Winnipeg Free Press, March 1, 2014